Tag Archives: West Bank

The Oppressed Have Become The Oppressors.

Posted on by

In an attempt to put the Israeli-Palestinian conflict into perspective, it should be noted that it all began with the Balfour Declaration of 1917 when the UK agreed to create a home for Jews who were being persecuted in Europe. Of course, Jews had historical links to the land in British-controlled Palestine, but it had been occupied by Palestinians for centuries.

The British intended for the land and the city of Jerusalem to be shared, and the rights of Palestinians protected. But Israel declared independence in 1948 and was recognized by the UN. That led to war with the five surrounding Arab nations and the displacement of roughly 750,000 Palestinians. Then in 1967, Israel captured more territory following a pre-emptive war with Egypt, Syria and Jordan leading to Israeli control of more than a million Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. As years passed, violence from both sides continued with Israel tightening its control of Palestinians in Gaza and clearing Palestinians from large tracts of the West Bank.

The growing Palestinian frustration and anger eventually led to the horrific events of October 7, 2023. As a result, Israel was certainly justified in attacking Hamas militants in Gaza. But the response has been vastly disproportionate and indiscriminate. Instead of an initial ground campaign to root out and kill or capture the militants, Israel chose to execute a massive bombing campaign followed by a large-scale invasion that has led to the deaths of tens of thousands of Gazans.

Indeed, given the brutality of Israel’s attacks on Gaza, the conflict can no longer be called a war. It now meets the very definition of ethnic cleansing.

Here are the numbers:

  • More than 52,000 Palestinians – mostly civilians – have been killed
  • More than 50,000 children have been killed or wounded
  • More than 1.9 million of the 2.1 million Gazans are displaced
  • At least 45 percent of the housing in Gaza has been destroyed
  • 75 percent of Gaza farmland has been destroyed
  • By January of this year, almost 7,000 Palestinians were being held on administrative detention (a practice that began long before October 7) without charges and without trials
  • Since 2023, conditions for Palestinians held in Israeli prisons have so declined that at least 70 prisoners have died
  • US trauma teams have reported seeing dozens of Palestinian children as young as 2 who were shot in the head or torso by Israeli snipers
  • 408 aid workers have been killed, including 280 from UNRWA
  • 176 journalists have been killed by Israeli forces
  • 374 medical personnel have been killed as a result of Israeli strikes
  • Hospitals and clinics have been damaged or destroyed by 1,644 Israeli strikes
  • The entire population of Gaza is facing food insecurity due to Israeli blockades
  • 250,000 Palestinians are currently facing starvation, and that number is expected to double
  • 71,000 children under the age of five suffer from acute malnutrition
  • 14,100 children under the age of five suffer severe malnutrition and death
  • Approximately 18,400 pregnant and breastfeeding women are expected to need malnutrition treatment to prevent irreversible and life-threatening health problems for both mothers and babies
  • At least 31 Palestinians were reportedly shot and killed by IDF soldiers at a recently opened food distribution site and hundreds more were wounded

Despite its nearly complete devastation of Gaza, no end of the conflict is in sight. Israel has announced plans to seize Gaza and stay for an unspecified time. And until very recently, Israel has blocked all humanitarian aid to Gaza, with some Israeli officials laughingly saying, “it will end Palestinian obesity.”

At the same time, Israeli settlers have increased attacks on Palestinians on the West Bank and the Israeli government approved 22 new settlements with the explanation that it will permanently end any possibility of a Palestinian state.

Yet the Trump administration continues to supply weapons to Israel despite its obvious war crimes. It has even shown a willingness to violate our constitutional right of free speech for even speaking out about the plight of Palestinians claiming that any expression of such sentiments constitutes antisemitism. But there is a vast difference between telling the truth about a violent and repressive government and engaging in hate speech against those who follow one of the world’s largest and oldest religions.

Criticism Is Not Antisemitism!

Posted on by

After the inhumane October 7 attacks on Israeli civilians by the militant faction of Hamas, it seems that some believe any criticism of the Israeli government’s long-standing mistreatment of Palestinians and its mass bombings of Gaza is antisemitic.

It represents the same kind of twisted accusations leveled against me and others for criticizing the US government during its misguided war in Vietnam. Being appalled by the Israeli government’s treatment of Palestinian civilians does not make one antisemitic any more than criticizing the Vietnam war made me un-American. And though it may be unpopular to criticize Israel’s conduct of its war on Hamas, I believe it’s important to add context to the situation.

The truth is the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been festering since 1948 with no solution in sight. And though Israel’s long-standing occupation of the West Bank and its siege of Gaza does not excuse the horrendous crimes committed by Hamas (nothing can), the untenable conditions under which Palestinian refugees have been forced to live has paved the way for the rise of Hamas and its terrorism.

Consider the fact that the population of Gaza consists of Palestinians who were forced to leave their homeland during the 1948 war in addition to generations of their descendants. Consider that, since the occupation of the West Bank, Israeli “settlers” have continued to harass and kill Palestinians in order to force them off their land. (According to the UN, more than 500 Palestinian men, women and children living in the West Bank have been killed by Jewish settlers this year – most before the October 7 attacks.)

Or consider the fact that Palestinians living within the Israeli borders have fewer rights than their Israeli counterparts. And, because they are not permitted to serve in the Israeli military, they do not qualify for many of the higher-paying jobs.

But perhaps the most grievous treatment of Palestinians is the Israeli concept of administrative detention. That’s the term given to the process of detaining individuals indefinitely without charges, without trials, and with no opportunity to defend themselves. Some have never even been told why they were being detained.

Of the more than 1,300 being held, it was reported that about half had been held for longer than 6 months. Many were children as young as 12. Indeed, according to Save The Children, between 500 and 1,000 such children are held in Israeli custody each year. A majority reported being beaten and strip searched.

They may have been detained for straying too close to the Israeli-Gaza border, for waving a Palestinian flag, for saying something an Israeli found offensive, or for throwing rocks at Israeli soldiers (a crime that could receive a maximum sentence of 20 years). And those are the lucky ones. Before the current war, an Israeli general admitted that IDF forces were under standing orders to shoot at the legs of child rock throwers!

These are the hostages released by Israel as part of the hostage exchange during the temporary ceasefire.

During that exchange, US media waited breathlessly to report every detail of the hostages released by Hamas. What was their condition of health? How were they treated? Where were they held? But few US media showed any curiosity about the hostages released by Israel.

If they had, they might have discovered that Palestinian families were not even allowed to celebrate the return of their loved ones or to publicly display any signs of joy.

One of the great ironies of the moment is that, while many innocent Palestinian civilians are being held under questionable circumstances, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is free despite facing criminal charges for corruption.

Does any of this excuse Hamas’ horrendous attacks? Of course not. They are to be despised, hunted down, and brought to trial for crimes against humanity. They must be held accountable. But so, too, must the Israelis who commit war crimes in return.

And when the dust from this war settles, we must find a way for Palestinians to finally enjoy freedom and self-governance. And to give both the Palestinian and Israeli people the safety and security they deserve.

The Real Israeli-Palestinian War.

Posted on by

Since the murder of 3 Israeli teenagers and the revenge killings of more than 2,000 Palestinians, Israel and Hamas have been engaged in a propaganda war. And it appears that Hamas is winning. The disproportionate Israeli attacks on Gaza, including air strikes on hospitals, schools and UN facilities, polls have caused the popularity of Hamas to soar. As recently as March, 58 percent of Gazans disapproved of Hamas. But since the conflict, the approval ratings of Hamas have skyrocketed. 94 percent of Palestinians now approve of the way Hamas conducted the war and 53 percent now believe that military conflict is the best way to achieve a Palestinian state.

This can only be made worse by the Israeli announcement that it is annexing another 1,000 acres of the occupied West Bank.

Despite polls showing that the majority of Israelis favor peace negotiations and a two-state solution, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu seems determined to provoke Hamas into a prolonged conflict. Israel points to the rockets being fired from Gaza, yet Israel controls everything that goes in and out of Gaza. As a result, Gazans have great difficulty gaining access to building materials and food. There are pronounced shortages of virtually everything.

So if rockets and other arms are being smuggled into the strip, it’s as much Israel’s fault as it is Gaza’s.

Even with the rockets and small arms, Hamas can have little effect on Israel. But thanks, in part, to the $3 billion a year in military aid from the US, Israel can wipe Gaza from the face of the Earth. Indeed, the UN estimates that it will take 20 years or more for Palestinians to rebuild Gaza neighborhoods providing, of course, Israel will allow concrete to cross the border. Yet, despite its military superiority, this is a war that Israel cannot win.

To understand why, one has to examine the region’s history. Even before World War II, Great Britain made the decision to help displaced Jews return to their “promised land.” To implement the plan, Britain drew up arbitrary borders which displaced thousands of Palestinians. In other words, Jewish refugees created Palestinian refugees. By 1948, there were already more than 700,000 Palestinian refugees crowded into Gaza, the West Bank and surrounding nations. With the creation of the State of Israel in 1948, Arab nations chose to fight back on behalf of the Palestinians. There has been almost constant fighting ever since.

After Israel won the 1967 war, it occupied Gaza and the West Bank. It filled the West Bank with Israeli settlements. Contrary to previous agreements, it claimed all of Jerusalem as its capital. It has placed a highly restrictive blockade on Gaza. It has refused to negotiate a peaceful solution since Hamas won control of the Palestinian Legislative Council in 2006. And it called for its special ally, the US, to block Palestinian membership in the UN.

Those are the facts. How you interpret them and which side you take is largely the result of the propaganda war.